1127 Holcomb Ave. Rapid City, SD
The Story of Sold
Here's The Story...
The seller hadn't owned this duplex long before he realized his investment thesis had shifted. The property was performing — an 8%+ cap rate, strong tenants, recent capital improvements — but his focus had moved elsewhere, and he needed to free up capital to pursue a different type of opportunity. The goal wasn't just to sell. It was to sell to the right buyer, quickly enough to keep his momentum. He brought the listing to Madison Shipman at Valente Realty. The property never hit the open market. It didn't need to.
THE CHALLENGE?
Off-market sales sound simple, but they require the right buyer to already exist in your network — someone who understands the asset, recognizes the value, and is ready to move. This duplex, while genuinely well-maintained and cash-flowing, had been on the seller's books for 183 days — longer than the Rapid City market average of 128 days for comparable investment properties. Carrying a property past market average while trying to pivot capital is friction the seller didn't need. The challenge was finding a motivated, qualified buyer without the runway of a traditional listing campaign.
Madison identified house-hacking as the angle. Rather than marketing this property broadly to seasoned investors competing on cap rate spreadsheets, she targeted buyers looking to offset their mortgage by living in one unit while the other generates income — a growing strategy among first-time real estate investors and owner-occupants building long-term wealth.
That framing changed the buyer pool entirely. A house-hacker sees this duplex differently than a portfolio investor: separate utilities, in-unit laundry in both units, premium outdoor space, a freshly paved driveway, new roof, new sewer line — these aren't just capital improvements, they're reasons not to worry about maintenance while you're learning the landlord business. Madison found exactly that buyer. The deal closed off-market.
$280,000 — Sold at 98.2% of asking price 183 Days on Market — Closed above market average DOM of 128 days; speed was secondary to finding the right buyer match 10 Showings — Focused showings with qualified prospects only 2 Offers — Competitive interest generated without open-market exposure
final sale price
showings
total online views
This sale worked because the strategy preceded the search. Identifying the right buyer profile before marketing the property meant every showing was intentional and every conversation was with someone who could actually close. A cash-flowing duplex with an 8%+ cap rate and recent upgrades sells itself — but only when it's in front of the right person. If you're holding an investment property and thinking about your next move, the conversation about who buys it matters as much as what you're asking for it.
If you're thinking about selling in the Black Hills, let's talk. We'd love to learn your situation, share what we're seeing in the market, and put together a plan that's built around your goals.